Crowdsourcing a revolution

On February 11, a revolution in Egypt culminated in President Hosni Mubarak resignation as President. As stated by CNN, "Inspired by a revolt in Tunisia and a page on Facebook", over 18 days mass protests coordinated predominantly through social media and cell phones (Twitter, Facebook, texting) brought down a dictatorial leader who had been in power for 30 years. The role of Social media in Mubarak's downfall has been hotly debated. On the one hand are the legions of news media outlets and bloggers who view Egypt as the first (but not the last) crowdsourced revolution (see The Instrumental Role of Social Media in Egypt on http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20030611-503544.html and E. B. Boyd's How Social Media Accelerated the Uprising in Egypt in Fast Company http://www.fastcompany.com/1722492/how-social-media-accelerated-the-uprising-in-egypt). They argue that the speed and efficiency of the revolution was directly attributable to the social media tools available to the drivers of the revolution, disenfranchised 18-24 year old Egyptians. If not for these tools, Mubarak would have rounded up and captured the leaders of the movement before they got traction with the general populace, and he'd still be in power today.

On the other side of the debate are those who feel social media's role is grossly overstated(see Malcolm Gladwell's article "Does Egypt need Twitter" in The New Yorker http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2011/02/does-egypt-need-twitter.html#ixzz1CwFMDA3b, and Jaikumar Vijayan of Computerworld at http://blogs.computerworld.com/17810/is_the_role_of_social_media_in_egypt_being_overstated). They point out, quite rightly, that crowd based revolutions have occurred throughout history (French Revolution anyone?) without any electronic social media tools.

While both sides have a valid point, it is clear that crowdsourcing and social media tools played a key role in the overthrow of the Government. With the speed of news dissemination and the ability to engage others quickly for protests, social media played a key role in moving from first protest to resignation within 18 days while providing a level of anonymity for the leaders until momentum clearly pointed to Mubarak's downfall. The key point here is anonymity for the leaders of the movement. With obscure Twitter and Facebook ID's, Mubarak's secret police didn't know who to round up. Traditionally despots have found and silenced opposition leaders before they could gain traction. In this case, without cooperation from two US based companies several thousand miles away, they couldn't find the individuals to arrest and interrogate. Finally, Social media tools are public (Twitter is publishing "Tweets from Tahir", a book of tweets that occurred during the revolution), which provides international support, sympathy, and ideas to help a movement succeed.

It took 4 years for the French Revolution to move from the storming of the Bastille to beheading Louis XVI. Wonder how much faster it would have happened today?

P-Comm - Participatory Commerce and the next wave of Social Marketing

Its been called Crowdsourcing, Social Merchandising, Social commerce, and a host of other names. My favorite name for it is Participatory Commerce (P-Comm), which I'd love to take credit for (I will take credit for the shortened version - P-Comm), but Mark Pincus (founder of Tribe Networks and Zynga, which counts Mafia Wars, Cafe World and Farmville among its addictive online games) coined the phrase in October of 2005. Essentially, it means that the classic one way model of the marketer developing his/her product or service in a lab or back room, and then using mass marketing with a lowest common denominator messaging strategy to sell it to consumers is quickly disappearing in several categories.

In the era of social networking, everyone is not only a critic, but can also become part of the product and marketing process. Some of the key aspects of Twitter reflect P-Comm, as their users created or defined many of the key elements of the service (including the name Tweets, #tags, and retweeting). The founders stepped back and let the users decide how their service should evolve, and then fostered initiatives that seemed to gain traction. Data indicates that ratings and reviews improves conversion rates on E-Commerce sites, as 70% of online consumers indicated they trusted opinions posted by other visitors (Nielsen Global Online Consumer Survey, 7/09). Blogs attract over 80 Million unique visitors, and mommy bloggers have become a key marketing partner for advertisers looking to reach mothers (At 1800flowers.com, we worked with Mommy bloggers to launch our Spot a Mom campaign last year, with strong results). Youtube has enabled anyone with a digital camera (or digital phone) to create their own mini-movies, and the world is a better place now that everyone can share the antics of their adorable pets. Last, but certainly not least, Facebook has reconnected millions of former roommates, boyfriends, girlfriends, and stalkers while providing a steady stream of what is going on in their lives.

P-Comm will take social networking and E-Commerce to the next level. How about asking your customers to create a new product or service for your company? Or asking them what offer they'd find compelling? Maybe they could develop your logo as part of a contest? We've already seen user generated commercials which advertisers have aired on the Superbowl, so why not outsource your advertising to your most loyal customers? The opportunities to have your customers create products, services, offers, and messages that are relevant to them turns one way marketing around and creates ownership. And if customers feel part of the process of creating and marketing your product or service, they'll be more loyal and more likely to provide the most effective marketing ever created - positive word of mouth.