The Pivot

The Pivot. That key moment when a business needs to change its business model, target, product - sometimes all three - dramatically to either survive or thrive. At larger companies, it can be wrenching to acknowledge that it is needed and even more difficult to follow through. The entire enterprise is build around a business model, and the realization that it's not working anymore is akin to (especially if the founder is still in control) to acknowledging their beautiful child has turned into a monster as an adult. Kodak had to transform itself with the rapid demise of film cameras (see http://buswk.co/8EEIae for an overview, http://bit.ly/mVcA63 for the details from a financial standpoint, and http://bit.ly/g5Hpmf for the most recent update). Jeffery Hayzlett is making a nice career writing books and lecturing about Kodak's success. IBM also pivoted, moving from a hardware to a services company. But for every big company success, there are legions of failures, in some cases because the pivot to the new business didn't match the speed at which the old business model was collapsing (GM and Chrysler, which survived only because of US bailouts, are two examples. So is Borders, which didn't get a bailout). To a large extent, that's what is happening in publishing today, particularly to newspapers. Newspapers are a Baby boomer item - people under the age of 35 simply don't read them in there paper form. I wrote a couple of years ago that the New York Times was making a critical mistake not charging a subscription fee (http://lewisgoldman.blogspot.com/2009/01/why-nytimescom-should-charge.html), which they finally corrected more than a year later. Their most recent financial results touted 224,000 online subscribers in the first quarter of launch. They've even started to advertise the digital version seperately from the print subscriptions. With the Ipad version, you'll see an acceleration of digital subscribers and, most importantly, re-engagement with a younger demographic which will pay off in advertising dollars. To complete the Pivot, they need to acknowledge their print version is for Boomers, increase the typeface (Please!), and focus on stories and news that that demo is interested in reading.

While big companies have trouble with the Pivot, start-ups can also struggle with it. The biggest impediment tends to be the passion and focus of start-up CEO's. They had a vision which they sold to investors, employees, the press, customers. Admitting that vision either won't work or is missing a bigger opportunity is an admission of failure, and many start-up founders struggle and delay the Pivot as a result. Having worked in business that wouldn't or couldn't Pivot, both big and small, it's clear to me that acknowledging the need for a pivot and then moving as rapidly as possible towards the new business model is critical for success. Otherwise competitors without the baggage of another business will pass you by.